Will UC Improve the Maintenance Picture?
Isn't it time for some innovation in communication system maintenance? Don't you think that UC solutions might actually bring some new options for maintenance and support, just as they bring new approaches for communications methods and solutions? It seems that should be possible, but there is little evidence of this occurring to date.
Most solutions which are labeled UC today are produced by the IP PBX vendors who perpetuate their high-priced maintenance offers. Since each vendor essentially has a monopoly on the maintenance of their software and their proprietary devices, maintenance is only subject to competitive pressures when an enterprise is replacing the entire communications system or bidding an entire system for a new location. In such cases, vendors may offer special pricing to win the competitive bid.
Even then, the special terms may only apply to the first year or two or three which are covered by the initial purchase contract. It may be hard to maintain special discount terms during subsequent maintenance contract renewals, unless there are accompanying major purchase decisions on the table.
Both the traditional PBX-based UC vendors and the new software-based UC vendors are consistent in charging for software maintenance on the basis of user licenses. While they argue that this fairly distributes costs across all of the users, it does not account for the complexity of the core system, which varies more by which features and configuration options are invoked than by the number of users.
Also, most vendors make it hard for customers to self-maintain their systems. Usually, access to updates and patches requires at least the minimum level of maintenance contract. This probably accounts for the high maintenance contract levels in the IP PBX-based UC category. The general estimates are that only 10% to 15% of enterprise PBX buyers take on the difficult task of self-maintenance of their systems, i.e. 85% to 90% of customers buy at least the basic maintenance contract. Nobody wants to be accountable for not having maintenance when the telephone or UC system goes down.
None of this is a trivial cost in Enterprise TCO calculations. Generally, minimum maintenance contracts range from $25 to $35 per station per year including voice mail, but not contact centers. Maximum protection maintenance contracts (24 x 7 coverage, monitoring, alarming, backup site options, on-site tech, etc.) can range between $70 and $95 per station per year. Thus, over a 10-year system life, maintenance of a $600 IP PBX station might cost between $250 and $950 per station, or between 42% and 158% of the initial purchase price.
Of course, one option is to move to cloud options, where maintenance is included in the service price. However, as shown in our Enterprise Connect 2012 TCO analysis and report, the cloud options are not the least cost, especially over a five-year term.
So, what might be done about this? Here are a few suggestions for both vendors and enterprise communication system and IT managers:
- Vendors: Improve your software so that maintenance costs can be lowered. Most customers would pay more initially for software that was demonstrably more reliable and manageable, especially if the improved reliability and manageability was reflected in a lower annual maintenance price.
- Vendors: Expand customer options through better, more transparent Partner maintenance programs and certifications. If multiple tiers of support were offered by a variety of Partners, customers could likely assemble the support model they preferred with the optimal cost structure, rather than being constrained by current vendor contract options. This would be especially attractive if IT Partners are able to participate, since those Partners are already involved in other infrastructure layers from Operations Centers, to servers and virtual machines, to desktop computing devices, to network connectivity.
- Vendors: Be real with your commitment to industry-provided hardware. Most enterprises already have optimal hardware and virtual machine procurement and maintenance contracts in place for those UC components.
- Enterprises: Consider variations in UC solutions and configurations based on applicable Use Cases. If you can place some users (e.g. mobile, remote, collaboration-intensive, etc.) on lower-TCO UC solutions, you can reduce your recurring maintenance costs. You can see some of these options in the report referenced above.
- Enterprises: Consider de-duplication of UC and IP PBX licenses and interoperation of the systems. In many cases, you already own multiple licenses per user and can meet the needs of most users with only one license and, therefore, one maintenance charge. System interoperation via SIP trunking or federation will allow all users to communicate with each other, even though each user is on a single specific system.
- Enterprises: Don't hesitate to negotiate on these points. Make your maintenance cost expectations known to your vendors. Your requests will have even more leverage if you have implemented or are at least pilot testing options such as suggested in points 4 and 5 above.
Hopefully, this post is a starting point for action and dialogue that will reduce the cost of the high-priced, single-source communication system maintenance contracts which most enterprise customers are experiencing. Preferably, costs will be reduced by making the products more reliable and manageable.
Your comments are welcome below, and your inquiries on this topic are more than welcome.
Tags
Start YourCustomized Search
SOLUTION AREA
SOLUTION PROVIDERS
- 8x8 (40) Apply 8x8 filter
- Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise (50) Apply Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise filter
- AT&T (44) Apply AT&T filter
- AudioCodes (49) Apply AudioCodes filter
- Avaya (397) Apply Avaya filter
- Cisco (574) Apply Cisco filter
- Dell (11) Apply Dell filter
- Five9 (54) Apply Five9 filter
- Fuze (39) Apply Fuze filter
- Genesys (100) Apply Genesys filter
- HP (98) Apply HP filter
- IBM (171) Apply IBM filter
- Jabra (9) Apply Jabra filter
- Logitech (56) Apply Logitech filter
- Lumen (4) Apply Lumen filter
- Masergy (50) Apply Masergy filter
- Microsoft (766) Apply Microsoft filter
- Mitel (233) Apply Mitel filter
- NEC (128) Apply NEC filter
- Nectar (58) Apply Nectar filter
- Polycom (95) Apply Polycom filter
- Ramp (37) Apply Ramp filter
- RingCentral (126) Apply RingCentral filter
- Sennheiser (18) Apply Sennheiser filter
- Slack (13) Apply Slack filter
- Tata Communications (59) Apply Tata Communications filter
- Unify (186) Apply Unify filter
- Vonage Business (80) Apply Vonage Business filter
- Yealink (8) Apply Yealink filter
- Zoom (21) Apply Zoom filter
- Acme Packet (24) Apply Acme Packet filter
- Allworx (2) Apply Allworx filter
- Arkadin (22) Apply Arkadin filter
- Aspect (34) Apply Aspect filter
- BT (25) Apply BT filter
- CaféX (8) Apply CaféX filter
- CallTower (14) Apply CallTower filter
- Clarity Connect (10) Apply Clarity Connect filter
- Continuant (1) Apply Continuant filter
- Damaka (4) Apply Damaka filter
- Dialogic (5) Apply Dialogic filter
- Dimension Data (44) Apply Dimension Data filter
- Empirix (11) Apply Empirix filter
- Enghouse Interactive (17) Apply Enghouse Interactive filter
- Inference Solutions (9) Apply Inference Solutions filter
- IntelePeer (27) Apply IntelePeer filter
- IR (11) Apply IR filter
- Jive (21) Apply Jive filter
- Kurmi Software (21) Apply Kurmi Software filter
- Lifesize (33) Apply Lifesize filter
- Lightware (3) Apply Lightware filter
- Mavenir (6) Apply Mavenir filter
- Modality Systems (8) Apply Modality Systems filter
- Momentum (36) Apply Momentum filter
- Netfortris (5) Apply Netfortris filter
- NetSapiens (6) Apply NetSapiens filter
- NewVoiceMedia (31) Apply NewVoiceMedia filter
- Nureva (26) Apply Nureva filter
- NUWAVE (5) Apply NUWAVE filter
- Orange (32) Apply Orange filter
- OVCC (8) Apply OVCC filter
- Panasonic (18) Apply Panasonic filter
- PanTerra Networks (9) Apply PanTerra Networks filter
- ScanSource (21) Apply ScanSource filter
- SIPPIO (3) Apply SIPPIO filter
- Snom (20) Apply Snom filter
- Star2Star (8) Apply Star2Star filter
- StarLeaf (12) Apply StarLeaf filter
- Tadiran Telecom (2) Apply Tadiran Telecom filter
- TekVizion (9) Apply TekVizion filter
- Unimax (7) Apply Unimax filter
- Verint (42) Apply Verint filter
- Voice4Net (2) Apply Voice4Net filter
- VOSS (85) Apply VOSS filter
- Voxbone (14) Apply Voxbone filter
- West (28) Apply West filter
- XO Communications (3) Apply XO Communications filter
- Yorktel (17) Apply Yorktel filter
- Zultys (2) Apply Zultys filter
- 3CX (8) Apply 3CX filter
- ADDASOUND (1) Apply ADDASOUND filter
- Aerohive (1) Apply Aerohive filter
- Aryaka (1) Apply Aryaka filter
- Asurion (22) Apply Asurion filter
- Avnet (7) Apply Avnet filter
- Bandwidth (5) Apply Bandwidth filter
- Calabrio (5) Apply Calabrio filter
- Consilium Software (13) Apply Consilium Software filter
- Drum (5) Apply Drum filter
- ESI (6) Apply ESI filter
- Esna (16) Apply Esna filter
- Exinda (2) Apply Exinda filter
- EZuce (3) Apply EZuce filter
- GUnify (6) Apply GUnify filter
- Highfive (4) Apply Highfive filter
- Huawei (47) Apply Huawei filter
- Imagicle (3) Apply Imagicle filter
- IPCortex (1) Apply IPCortex filter
- KnoahSoft (1) Apply KnoahSoft filter
- KOVA (1) Apply KOVA filter
- Logmein (9) Apply Logmein filter
- Metropolis Technologies (4) Apply Metropolis Technologies filter
- Mutare (2) Apply Mutare filter
- NextPlane (27) Apply NextPlane filter
- Ooma (16) Apply Ooma filter
- Patton (11) Apply Patton filter
- Radish Systems (1) Apply Radish Systems filter
- Radisys (3) Apply Radisys filter
- Shango (1) Apply Shango filter
- SMART (163) Apply SMART filter
- Stack8 (1) Apply Stack8 filter
- Swyx (1) Apply Swyx filter
- TrueConf (4) Apply TrueConf filter
- UJET (13) Apply UJET filter
- Voximplant (3) Apply Voximplant filter
CONTENT TYPE
- BC Expert Insights Market (43) Apply BC Expert Insights Market filter
- BC Expert Insights Objective - Vendor Neutral (42) Apply BC Expert Insights Objective - Vendor Neutral filter
- BC Expert Insights Planning (15) Apply BC Expert Insights Planning filter
- BC Expert Insights Solution (12) Apply BC Expert Insights Solution filter
- BC Expert Insights Vendor (80) Apply BC Expert Insights Vendor filter
- BC Expert Insights Vendor Solution (146) Apply BC Expert Insights Vendor Solution filter
- BC Expert Roundtable (133) Apply BC Expert Roundtable filter
- Bcs Webinar (0)
- Bcs Webinar Registration (0)
- Best Practice (38) Apply Best Practice filter
- Buyer Guide (14) Apply Buyer Guide filter
- Case Study (29) Apply Case Study filter
- Executive Interview (145) Apply Executive Interview filter
- Expert Roundtable (450) Apply Expert Roundtable filter
- Guest Contributions (35) Apply Guest Contributions filter
- Multimedia (38) Apply Multimedia filter
- News Analysis (2081) Apply News Analysis filter
- Newsfeed Article (1303) Apply Newsfeed Article filter
- Newsfeed Article (1) Apply Newsfeed Article filter
- Thought Leadership (21) Apply Thought Leadership filter
- Vendor Collateral (211) Apply Vendor Collateral filter
- Vendor Resource Best Practices (24) Apply Vendor Resource Best Practices filter
- Vendor Resource Buyers Guides (2) Apply Vendor Resource Buyers Guides filter
- Vendor Resource Multimedia Content (4) Apply Vendor Resource Multimedia Content filter
- Vendor Resource White Paper (4) Apply Vendor Resource White Paper filter
- Webinar (13) Apply Webinar filter
- Webinars (7) Apply Webinars filter
- White Paper (64) Apply White Paper filter
MORE FILTERS
INDUSTRY
- Banking And Investment (800) Apply Banking And Investment filter
- Education (446) Apply Education filter
- Energy And Utilities (487) Apply Energy And Utilities filter
- Finance (12) Apply Finance filter
- Government (675) Apply Government filter
- Healthcare (482) Apply Healthcare filter
- Hospitality (180) Apply Hospitality filter
- Insurance (100) Apply Insurance filter
- Manufacturing (704) Apply Manufacturing filter
- Media/Publishing (422) Apply Media/Publishing filter
- None (43) Apply None filter
- Professional Services (745) Apply Professional Services filter
- Retail & Distribution (798) Apply Retail & Distribution filter
- Technology (1611) Apply Technology filter
- Transportation (110) Apply Transportation filter
Comments
There are currently no comments on this article.
You must be a registered user to make comments